Missouri Insurance Agencies

Independent agencies, by city

Missouri › Columbia

Independent insurance agencies in Columbia, Missouri

These are the 12 independent insurance agencies we found with offices in Columbia and nearby towns in Boone County, each checked against the agency's own website on 2 October 2026. An independent agency can place insurance with more than one insurance company. The list is alphabetical by town and doesn't rank or recommend anyone.

Compiled by Tyler Mayberry for Cirlet · Data checked

Agencies listed12
TownsAshland and Columbia
List personal lines (home, auto)12 of 12
List commercial lines (business)12 of 12
List farm insurance6 of 12
Also list life or health insurance10 of 12
Insurance companies named most often on these agencies' sitesProgressive (8), Liberty Mutual (8), Foremost (7), Travelers (7), American Modern (6), Barton Mutual (6), The Hartford (6), Missouri Employers Mutual (6). Counted across the 10 agencies that name their companies.
Checked

Columbia is the seat of Boone County and home of the University of Missouri.

Before you call an agency

Check that the agent is licensed in Missouri with the state's Find an Insurance Agent/Agency search (how: checking an agent's license). The Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance answers questions on its Insurance Consumer Hotline, 800-726-7390. This site gives no insurance advice and gets nothing when you call an agency.

Ashland

Angell & Co.

Address
509 E Broadway, Ashland, MO 65010
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Farm, Life, Healthauto, home, farm, business, health, life
Insurance companies named on its site
Acuity, Allied, Allstate, American Modern, Anthem, Auto-Owners, Barton Mutual, Billings Mutual, CFM Insurance, Farmers Mutual of Macon, Foremost, Grinnell Mutual, GuideOne, The Hartford, Madison Mutual, Missouri Employers Mutual, Mutual of Omaha, Progressive, Rain and Hail, Safeco, Travelers, UnitedHealthcare

Checked against its own website on . Correct or remove this listing

South County Realty – The Glascock Agency

Address
504 E Broadway, Ashland, MO 65010
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Life, Bondshome, auto, boat, umbrella, life, business, bonds
Insurance companies named on its site
Missouri Employers Mutual, Foremost, Barton Mutual, Cornerstone National, Safeco, Billings Mutual, Progressive

Checked against its own website on . Correct or remove this listing

Columbia

Gallaher Insurance Group

Address
401 Locust Street, Ste 301, Columbia, MO 65201
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Life, Healthauto, home, motorcycle, business, life, health
Insurance companies named on its site
Accident Fund, Acuity, Allstate, Anthem, Chubb, Cincinnati, CNA, FCCI, FirstComp, Foremost, GEICO, Grinnell, Hagerty, Liberty Mutual, Markel, Nationwide, Philadelphia Insurance, Progressive, Selective, Travelers

Checked against its own website on . Correct or remove this listing

Harrison Agency, Inc.

Address
2100 Whitegate Drive, Columbia, MO 65202
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Life, Health, Benefitshome, auto, valuable possessions, high net worth, umbrella, business owners, general liability, commercial property, workers comp, employee benefits, life
Insurance companies named on its site
Acuity, Assurant Employee Benefits, Auto-Owners, Banner Life, Barton Mutual, Chubb, Columbia Insurance Group, CWG (a Berkley company), FirstComp, Foremost, Genworth, Liberty Mutual, Madison Mutual, Markel, Missouri Employers Mutual, Mutual of Omaha, Nationwide, Philadelphia Insurance Companies, Progressive, Protective, UnitedHealthcare

Checked against its own website on . Correct or remove this listing

Hereth Insurance Consulting

Address
1207 W. Broadway, Suite 103, Columbia, MO 65203
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Farm, Life, Health, Benefitsauto, home, renters, umbrella, business, workers comp, contractors, farm, life, health, employee benefits
Insurance companies named on its site
Auto-Owners, American Modern, American Strategic Insurance, Barton County Mutual, CFM Insurance, Clearcover, CNA, Dairyland, Encompass, Frankenmuth, Grinnell Mutual, Hagerty, The Hartford, Hippo, Liberty Mutual, Markel, Missouri Employers Mutual, National General, Openly, Progressive, Safeco, SECURA, State Auto, Stillwater, Travelers, West Bend

Checked against its own website on . Correct or remove this listing

Heritage Advises

Address
1517 Chapel Hill Rd #400, Columbia, MO 65203
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Life, Health, Medicarehome, auto, umbrella, renters, pet, motorcycle, condo, boat, specialty dwelling, business, life
Insurance companies named on its site
None named on its site

Checked against its own website on . Correct or remove this listing

Insurance Plus, LLC

Address
1604 Business Loop 70W, Columbia, MO 65202
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Life, Health, Benefits, Medicarehome, auto, umbrella, renters, business, workers comp, employee benefits, life, health, pet
Insurance companies named on its site
Travelers, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide, Progressive, Barton Mutual, American Modern, State Auto, Allstate, Openly, Foremost, Aegis, CFM Insurance, Grinnell Mutual, Hagerty, Berkshire Hathaway GUARD, Branch, ICW Group, Columbia Insurance Group, Steadily, National General, Clearcover, The Hartford, Markel, Chubb, US Assure, SECURA, Missouri Employers Mutual, Pie Insurance

Checked against its own website on . Correct or remove this listing

Kasmann Insurance Agency, Inc.

Address
116 N Garth Ave, Columbia, MO 65203
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Farm, Lifeauto, home, renters, boat, motorcycle, umbrella, small business, farm, life
Insurance companies named on its site
Auto-Owners, American Modern, Barton Mutual, Berkley One, Columbia Insurance, Dairyland, Foremost, GEICO, GuideOne, Liberty Mutual, Missouri Employers Mutual, Palomar, Philadelphia Insurance, Progressive, RLI, The General, Travelers, West Bend

Checked against its own website on . Correct or remove this listing

Mid-America Specialty Markets

Address
2800 Forum Blvd Ste 4B, Columbia, MO 65203
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Farm, Life, Health, Bondsbusiness, workers comp, bonds, farm and crop, auto, home, renters, condo, boat, motorcycle, umbrella, life
Insurance companies named on its site
None named on its site

Checked against its own website on . Correct or remove this listing

Oswald Crow Agency

Address
108 E. Green Meadows Rd. Ste 7, Columbia, MO 65203
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Farm, Life, Health, Medicare, Bondsauto, home, renters, condo, boat, motorcycle, umbrella, business, general liability, workers comp, bonds, farm, crop and livestock, life, health
Insurance companies named on its site
Allianz, Allstate, AmTrust, American Modern, Barton Mutual, Berkshire Hathaway, CFM Insurance, Chubb, CNA, Columbia Insurance, EMC, Farmers Mutual, Foremost, Great American, Grinnell Mutual, Hagerty, The Hartford, Liberty Mutual, Markel, MEM, MetLife

Checked against its own website on . Correct or remove this listing

Swartz Premier Group Insurance

Address
204D Peach Way, Columbia, MO 65203
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Farmauto, home, boat, commercial, farm
Insurance companies named on its site
American Modern, AmTrust, Berkshire Hathaway, Chubb, Encompass, Hagerty, Hippo, Kemper, Liberty Mutual, MetLife, Nationwide, Openly, Safeco, State Auto, Stillwater, The Hartford, Travelers, USLI

Checked against its own website on . Correct or remove this listing

The Insurance Shop, LLC

Address
3901 South Providence Rd Ste B, Columbia, MO 65203
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Benefits, Bondsgeneral liability, professional liability, business owners, workers comp, commercial auto, commercial property, bonds, cyber, home, auto
Insurance companies named on its site
AIG, The Hartford, Markel, MetLife, Progressive, USLI, Travelers, State Auto, Safeco, Philadelphia Insurance, Liberty Mutual, Encompass, CNA Surety, BTIS, Atlas, Accident Fund, AMERISAFE, AmTrust, Berkshire Hathaway, Employers

Checked against its own website on . Correct or remove this listing

Is an independent agency in Columbia missing, or is your agency's listing wrong? Claim, add or update a listing.