MissouriInsurance Agencies

The Missouri directory

Independent insurance agencies in Cape Girardeau

10 agencies

10 independent agencies in Cape Girardeau and Jackson, across 2 towns. On their own websites, all 10 list home and auto insurance and 9 of 10 list business insurance. Before you call, you can check any agent with the state's free Missouri Department of Insurance agent lookup, or read how independent agents differ from captive agents.

Record checks: 7 October 2026 to 28 October 2026 Our sources & method

About this area

Cape Girardeau is on the Mississippi River in southeast Missouri. This page also lists offices in Jackson, the seat of Cape Girardeau County.

Listed alphabetically by town & nameAgency-stated information

Cape Girardeau8 agencies

Arnold Insurance

Cape Girardeau

Personal, Commercial, Life, Health, Bonds

800-397-2427WebsiteDirections

Details
Address
875 North Kingshighway Blvd, Cape Girardeau, MO 63701
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Life, Health, Bondsauto, home, general liability, property, towing, bonding, business owners, group health, life
Insurance companies named on its site
Auto-Owners, SECURA, Cincinnati, Blue Cross
Independence, in its own words
We are more than an insurance brokerage - we’re your trusted partner in protecting what matters most Source page

Record checked . Sources: Agency website: home page (checked ); Agency website: about page (checked ); Insurance company agent profile: progressiveagent.com (checked ). Correct or remove this listing · Use the online form

Capital Insurance & Associates, Inc.

Cape Girardeau

Personal, Commercial, Health, Bonds

573-335-2300WebsiteDirections

Details
Address
326 S Broadview, Cape Girardeau, MO 63703
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Health, Bondsauto, homeowners, renters, motorcycle, umbrella, flood, business, contractors, general liability, workers comp, bonds, health
Insurance companies named on its site
American Modern, Blue Cross Blue Shield, CNA, Columbia Insurance Group, GuideOne, The Hartford, Liberty Mutual, Markel, Missouri Employers Mutual, Nationwide, Philadelphia American Life, Progressive, Safeco, Travelers
Independence, in its own words
As a truly independent agency our access to a wide variety of carriers allows us to meet nearly every insurance need Source page

Record checked . Sources: Agency website: home page (checked ); Agency website: carriers page (checked ); Agency website: about page (checked ); Agency website: about page (checked ). Correct or remove this listing · Use the online form

Coalter Insurance Group

Cape Girardeau

Personal, Commercial, Life, Benefits

573-339-1222WebsiteDirections

Details
Address
1001 Independence St., Cape Girardeau, MO 63703
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Life, Benefitshome, auto, toys, business, employee benefits, life
Insurance companies named on its site
Aetna, Allstate, Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Mutual of Omaha, Travelers, Progressive, UnitedHealthcare, Safeco, Liberty Mutual, The Hartford, CFM Insurance, State Auto, Transamerica
Independence, in its own words
As a full-service broker with multiple carriers, we can work with you to find a plan that fits your unique needs so you can just focus on “doing you.” Source page

Record checked . Sources: Agency website: about page (checked ); Agency website: carriers page (checked ); Agency website: about page (checked ); Agency website: independence wording (checked ). Correct or remove this listing · Use the online form

Discount Insurance Group

Cape Girardeau

Personal

573-339-1100WebsiteDirections

Details
Address
1009 N. Kingshighway, Cape Girardeau, MO 63701
Lines it lists
Personalauto, SR22, non-owner, motorcycle, boat, RV, mobile home
Insurance companies named on its site
Not recorded
Independence, in its own words
Discount Insurance Group is an independent agency that specializes in personal insurance products Source page

Record checked . Sources: Agency website: about page (checked ); Agency website: home page (checked ). Correct or remove this listing · Use the online form

Hoesli Insurance Agency

Cape Girardeau

Personal, Commercial

573-290-7777WebsiteDirections

Details
Address
338 Broadway St Suite 505, Cape Girardeau, MO 63701
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercialhome, auto, business
Insurance companies named on its site
Not recorded
Independence, in its own words
our agency is 100% independent of any one company Source page

Record checked . Sources: Agency website: about page (checked ); Agency website: home page (checked ). Correct or remove this listing · Use the online form

The Daniel & Henry Co.

Cape Girardeau

Personal, Commercial, Benefits

573-335-7956WebsiteDirections

Details
Address
1435 North Mount Auburn Road, Suite 100, Cape Girardeau, MO 63701
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Benefitsbusiness insurance, risk management, employee benefits, personal insurance
Insurance companies named on its site
Acuity, CNA, Chubb, Cincinnati, Great West Casualty, Hanover, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide, Philadelphia Insurance, Private Client Select, PURE, Safeco, Selective, The Hartford, Travelers, West Bend
Independence, in its own words
As an independent, broker-owned firm, our clients simply matter more Source page

Record checked . Sources: Agency website: contact page (checked ); Agency website: home page (checked ); Agency website: about page (checked ). Correct or remove this listing · Use the online form

W.E. Walker-Lakenan Insurance

Cape Girardeau

Personal, Commercial

573-335-3307WebsiteDirections

Details
Address
117 South Broadview, Cape Girardeau, MO 63703
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercialpersonal insurance, commercial insurance
Insurance companies named on its site
Accident Fund, Acuity, AmTrust, Auto-Owners, Barton Mutual, Berkshire Hathaway, CNA, Chubb, Cincinnati, Employers, GuideOne, The Hartford, Liberty Mutual, Markel, Missouri Employers Mutual, Nationwide, Openly, Philadelphia Insurance, Progressive, RLI
Independence, in its own words
Walker-Lakenan is an independent insurance agency serving the insurance needs of families and business in the Cape Girardeau, Jackson and surrounding Source page

Record checked . Sources: Agency website: home page (checked ). Correct or remove this listing · Use the online form

Weiss Insurance Agency

Cape Girardeau

Personal, Commercial, Farm, Life, Health

573-334-5086WebsiteDirections

Details
Address
113 S. Broadview, Cape Girardeau, MO 63703
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Farm, Life, Healthauto, home, boat, RV, farm, business, health, life
Insurance companies named on its site
American Modern, Bristol West, Chubb, Cincinnati, CNA, Columbia Insurance, Foremost, Hagerty, Hanover, The Hartford, Liberty Mutual, MEM, National General, Nationwide, PURE, Progressive, RLI, Safeco, Selective, Travelers, Vault
Independence, in its own words
As independent insurance brokers, we are not tied to a single carrier Source page

Record checked . Sources: Agency website: contact page (checked ); Agency website: home page (checked ). Correct or remove this listing · Use the online form

Jackson2 agencies

Golden Rule Insurance Associates

Jackson

Personal, Commercial

573-866-2699WebsiteDirections

Details
Address
1600 S. Hope St., Jackson, MO 63755
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercialpersonal insurance, commercial insurance
Insurance companies named on its site
Not recorded
Independence, in its own words
Golden Rule Insurance is an independent insurance agency Source page

Record checked . Sources: Agency website: about page (checked ); Agency website: about page (checked ); Agency website: contact page (checked ). Correct or remove this listing · Use the online form

Wallace & Associates Insurance Agency LLC

Jackson

Personal, Commercial, Life

573-243-0022WebsiteDirections

Details
Address
231 E. Main St, Jackson, MO 63755
Lines it lists
Personal, Commercial, Lifeauto, classic car, motorcycle, home, specialty dwelling, mobile home, renters, ATV/UTV, boat, RV, umbrella, life, business
Insurance companies named on its site
Openly, Aegis, Steadily, US Assure, USLI, National General, Allstate, CFM Insurance, Texas County Mutual, Nationwide, Travelers, State Auto, Progressive, Safeco, RLI, The Hartford, Burns & Wilcox, Dairyland, American Modern, Palomar, Liberty Mutual, Hagerty
Independence, in its own words
We work with a variety of insurance companies to offer a wide array of coverages in many different fields. Source page

Record checked . Sources: Agency website: carriers page (checked ); Agency website: about page (checked ); Agency website: home page (checked ). Correct or remove this listing · Use the online form

About this list
Agencies listed10
TownsCape Girardeau and Jackson
List personal lines (home, auto)10 of 10
List commercial lines (business)9 of 10
List farm insurance1 of 10
Also list life or health insurance5 of 10
Insurance companies named most often on these agencies' sitesThe Hartford (6), Liberty Mutual (6), Nationwide (5), Progressive (5), Safeco (5), Travelers (5), Cincinnati (4), CNA (4). Counted across the 7 agencies that name their companies.
Record checks7 October 2026 to 28 October 2026

Check a license using Missouri's Find an Insurance Agent/Agency search. How to check a license. Insurance Consumer Hotline: 800-726-7390.

Is an independent agency in Cape Girardeau missing, or is your agency's listing wrong? Claim, add or update a listing.